| I feel like I've got TV whiplash, here. |
[ |
October 19th,
2010 12:33 pm
| ] |
I know y'all are a bunch of Mad Men fans, so I figured I'd cross-post this here!
I've only just started watching last week, but have marathoned my way through all of S1 and most of S2, and I am really confused.
In S1, Don was a selfish, compartmentalized, borderline sociopathic dude who was constantly managing a hundred and one lies at any given time (only some of which were to clients), carrying on emotional affairs, and patronizing his wife. He likes his reputation and isn't afraid of being a complete asshole. He's cut-throat in business -- he doesn't actually care about clients so long as they bring in money, and he doesn't really care about any other employees besides maybe Roger Sterling, who is his friend and mentor. Betty was meek, repressed, empathetic, gullible, never said a bad word about anybody even if it killed her, could turn any negative into a positive (no matter how insipid), was easy to push around, and lived for her kids. She was a loving, caretaking mother, and really obviously did not approve of domestic violence.
In S2, all of a sudden Betty is shrill, petty, hypercritical, alienated from her kids and trying to bully Don into spanking them, more concerned with horseback riding (??? and this is apparently a longtime passion of hers? since when?) than with her role as a wife and mother, constantly seeing everything in a negative light, and picks fight with Don all the time by giving him lip. Don's having rape-fantasy sex with some trashy alcoholic comedian's wife, is somehow offended that he's got a reputation with the ladies, and is offended that people think he might not be a paragon of virtue. He's now got a ~sympathetic past~ (instead of an obscure past in which he couldn't see that his step-mother was good to him and then proved his sociopathic tendencies by stealing his army superior's identity and letting his family think he was dead, as it was presented in S1), is the loving, involved father, is the good parent, and is super loyal to his clients and colleagues. For no reason I can possibly fathom (if I consider his S1 self, anyway), he tracked Peggy down to visit her in the hospital and is now her mentor. Etc.
And there was no transition between the two. It's like the show got completely different writers over the gap between seasons or something and the new ones didn't bother to actually watch S1, though obviously that's not the case. From what I've been reading of everybody's posts RE the latest season finale, Don is A Decent Guy And A Good Father while Betty Is A Selfish Harpy are the current portrayals, but until I started S2 yesterday, I couldn't figure out where the hell that was coming from. And I guess now I know. But it definitely came out of nowhere all of a sudden with the start of S2, and it seems so schizophrenic and disconnected with the events of S1 that I can't really approve. I suppose I'll get used to it if they stay consistent after this, but I still hope they at least dialed it back a little in the episodes to follow, because right now it's really heavy-handed and the blatant mischaracterization is driving me up the wall. Yikes.
Does anybody else remember noticing this at the time, or did the gap between seasons (in which people have time to forget) do a pretty good job of hiding it?
|
|